← Back to the Game ShelfThe Stoic Opposition
THE STOIC
OPPOSITION
๐Ÿฆ‰
TIMIDI MATER
NON FLET

EOB

Explanation of Benefits โ€” what would you do differently?
This is not a bill. It says so right on it โ€” and then the bills arrive anyway, one envelope at a time, from people who were all in the same room. You are the patient. You did everything right: you have insurance, you went in-network, you needed care three times this year. Open the mail. Read every line. Then answer the only question this game asks: what would you do differently?
Nobody in this game is a villain. There is no villain. There is only arithmetic โ€” every figure on every bill reconciles, and you can check it. The plan below is fictional; the margin and waste figures in the sources panel are real and cited.

๐Ÿ“‹ Your plan (fictional, fixed for the whole game)

Annual deductible$1,500
Coinsurance after deductible20% you / 80% plan
Office visit copay$40 (no deductible)
Out-of-pocket maximum$4,000 โ€” after this, the plan pays 100%

Disclosed assumptions: every patient payment (copays included) counts toward the out-of-pocket maximum, and the deductible carries across all three episodes, in order โ€” the way a real plan year works. Each bill also shows what the care cost to deliver, the margin built into its allowed amount, and the administration in between. On each bill, margin rates marked โ—† come from the sourced panel; rates marked โ—‡ are disclosed scenario assumptions.


โœ‰๏ธ The Mailbox

Three episodes of care. The bills for each arrive separately โ€” an inpatient stay arrives as five separate claims, because it does.

๐Ÿ“Š The Ledger

A running bar splits every billed dollar into the cost of care, administration, margin โ€” and the part that was never real money at all.

๐Ÿ”ง Your Turn

After each episode: cut a margin, consolidate the bills, strip duplicate admin. Every cut works โ€” and every cut costs something somewhere else. No free wins.
โœ‰๏ธ Episode 1 / 3๐ŸŽฏ Deductible met $0 / $1,500๐Ÿ›ก๏ธ Out-of-pocket $0 / $4,000๐Ÿ’ธ You have paid $0๐Ÿงพ Bills opened 0

Where the billed money is going โ€” running ledger

Cost of delivering care $0 ยท Administration & billing $0 ยท Margin / profit $0 ยท Written off โ€” never existed $0

๐Ÿ“š Sources & real numbers

โ—† Typical hospital operating margin โ‰ˆ 2%. Kaufman Hall National Hospital Flash Report: about 2.1% for calendar 2024, roughly 1.7โ€“2.5% through 2025. Hospital and facility bills in this game use 2%.

โ—† Health insurer profit margins are typically no more than a few percent of premiums โ€” about 2โ€“4% net (KFF, 2026). Thin margins on enormous volume is still enormous money; the game shows margins per bill, and the plan's own admin-and-margin slice is governed by the next figure.

โ—† The ACA medical loss ratio: plans must spend 80โ€“85% of premiums on care and quality improvement, leaving 15โ€“20% for administration and profit combined. That is a legal cap on the insurer's slice โ€” note that provider-side administration (hospital billing departments, coding, claims on both ends) sits outside that cap, inside the allowed amounts you just read.

โ—† Waste: Shrank et al., JAMA 2019, estimated total waste in US health care at $760โ€“935 billion a year โ€” roughly 25% of spending โ€” with administrative complexity the largest single domain, about $266 billion a year. Broader estimates put administration at 15โ€“25% of all health spending. In this game, administration took the share shown on your end screen โ€” computed from the bills, not asserted.

โ—‡ Disclosed scenario assumptions (labelled โ—‡ on the bills): non-hospital margin rates (physician, surgery, anesthesia, radiology, laboratory), the provider delivery costs, the billed charges, and the plan terms are fictional-but-typical scenario parameters, chosen so the arithmetic is clean enough to check by hand. The billed-to-allowed gaps are large because real chargemaster gaps are large; any specific bill here is an illustration, not a claim about a real provider.

The formula on every bill (so you can audit us): Allowed = delivery cost + administration + margin. Billed = Allowed + contractual write-off. You owe + plan paid = Allowed. You owe = copay, or deductible-remaining first, then 20% coinsurance on the rest โ€” never more than what is left of your $4,000 out-of-pocket maximum.